Skip to content

Engineered Hardwood vs Vinyl Plank Flooring: Which one to choose?

    Engineered Hardwood vs Vinyl Plank Flooring

    One is affordable, water-resistance, scratch-resistant; the other is hard, long-lasting, real hardwood. So which one to choose? It becomes difficult to make a choice between Engineered hardwood vs vinyl plank. There are a lot of qualities that make them stand equal to each other. So to make a choice between them, it is essential to get an in-detail differentiation between Enginned hardwood vs Vinyl Plank. 

    This article will facilitate complete and in-depth differences between engineered hardwood vs vinyl plank. Moreover, we will also facilitate which one is better among them to ease your choice. But first, let’s know about each of them in brief!

    What is Vinyl Flooring?

    When you’re remodeling or building a new home, vinyl floors are a great choice because they’re cheap, flexible, and easy to change.

    Vinyl flooring is a man-made product that is made entirely of plastic. Solid Vinyl is covered in a printed vinyl layer, then a wear layer on top of a wear layer, and then a solid layer on top of a wear layer. Layers of vinyl flooring make a surface that is impermeable and watertight.

    Vinyl flooring comes in a wide range of styles and prices, from low-cost sheet vinyl to high-end luxury planks.

    Vinyl flooring comes in thicknesses of 1.5 millimeters (mm) to 5 millimeters (mm).

    For rooms that get a lot of moisture, Vinyl is a good choice. Vinyl isn’t going to get wet.

    Types of Vinyl: 

    1. Vinyl Plank
    2. WPC Vinyl
    3. Rigid Core

    What is Engineered Wood Flooring?

    Multiple ply layers make up engineered hardwoods, which feature a hardwood wear layer on top of their hardwood core. Each layer of plywood is crisscrossed in various orientations to create a core that supports the top and lower layers of natural wood. Different types of hardwood are used in the engineered wood.

    Engineered hardwoods typically have a wear layer of 2mm and a total thickness of 3mm. Your floor will not only appear like hardwood flooring but it will truly be made of genuine wood when you install engineered wood flooring.

    Engineered hardwood flooring comes in various types with different features like the chance of expanding, shifting, or contracting when it is exposed to humidity, temperature, and water.

    Engineered hardwood vs Vinyl Plank Differences:

    Both these flooring options are better than other solid hardwood flooring options. But to make a choice, it is important to know the feature of each one & which one is better. So here is the in-depth difference between engineered hardwood vs vinyl plank based on various features: 

    1) Appearance

    At a tenth of the cost of real wood, engineered hardwood has the same look and feel. Engineered hardwood is constructed from layers of actual wood and will thus be available in the same finish options as hardwood.

    While vinyl plank has a striking resemblance to genuine wood, it is far softer underfoot and does not have the authentic wood sound associated with natural hardwood floors. Additionally, it is available in a variety of colors and designs.

    So, if you want variety in appearance, then surely Vinyl will provide that. But if you want an aesthetic look, then engineered hardwood is the best option.

    2) Vinyl vs Laminate Flooring cost

    In general, people think that engineered hardwood is cheaper than real hardwood, and it usually costs between $4 and $10 per square foot. However, you might also have to think about the cost of hiring a professional, which could cost you between $3 and $8 per square foot.

    Luxury vinyl plank costs between $2.50 to $5 per square foot, which is less expensive than engineered hardwood. When compared to engineered hardwood, the cost of installation is between $1 – $3 per square foot.

    So yes, Vinyl flooring is surely less expensive than Engineered wood flooring. 

    3) Ease of Installation

    Both floors can be put down right over old subfloors, which is a good thing. Engineered hardwood floors can be installed in a variety of ways, including by gluing, stapling, or floating, all of which are simple enough that the homeowner can complete them.

    However, it’s easier to put vinyl planks in than to put engineered hardwood planks in. There are two methods for installing vinyl planks: floating or peel-and-stick. Floating floor installation of vinyl planks is as simple as clicking the planks together along with their tongue and groove. Just apply the planks to the floor with peel-and-stick flooring.

    So it is easier to install vinyl flooring than engineered wood flooring. 

    4) Moisture Resistance

    Engineered hardwood was created to be moisture resistant, which is a common complaint about traditional hardwoods. Moisture can be kept at bay by the plywood foundation, but it couldn’t handle anything heavier.

    Water-prone spaces such as bathrooms and kitchens are best served by vinyl plank flooring. Vinyl plank flooring is a great option if you have kids who come in from the pool with wet feet because it’s easy to clean and maintain.

    In terms of water resistance, the Vinyl Plank is the best option than any other flooring option and even engineered hardwood flooring. 

    5) Cleaning & Maintenance 

    Use manufacturer-approved cleaning products and avoid aggressive cleaning solutions that may potentially harm the finish of your engineered hardwood flooring. Engineered wood floors might be damaged if you use any brush or broom and a wet mop or even a steam cleaner to clean them.

    When sweeping, you should use soft-bristled brushes and a microfiber mop that must be squeezed correctly to remove as much moisture from the floor as possible throughout the cleaning process, despite vinyl plank flooring’s excellent water and scratching resistance.

    So in terms of cleaning and maintenance, Vinyl planks are easier to clean. 

    6) Durability

    Because of its multilayered core, engineered hardwood is extremely stable and durable. Varieties of high quality can endure up to fifty years. However, the wood used in its construction is a porous substance; therefore, it cannot be considered waterproof. The top layer may have apparent scratches, but it is impervious to additional damage, such as dents. 

    The expected lifespan of vinyl plank flooring is 25 years, which is surely less than that of engineered hardwood, although it is not as long-lasting as engineered hardwood. Scratches and damage don’t have a chance against it. Due to its water resistance, vinyl plank flooring is a great option for places with high humidity levels.

    So in terms of durability & longevity, surely Engineered wood flooring is a better option. 

    7) Sunlight Susceptibility

    Wood is highly susceptible to sunlight, and as a result, it will eventually fade. To some extent, the color of your hardwood flooring will depend on the type of wood you’ve chosen; some will get lighter with time, while others will become darker.

    Long-term sunlight exposure can also cause vinyl plank flooring to fade, despite its excellent resistance to things like scratches and wetness. As a result, tinted windows or window coverings may be required to keep it safe.

    So both options are susceptible to sunlight, so try to keep your windows tinted. 

    8) Luxury Vinyl Plank vs Engineered Hardwood Resale Value

    Despite the lack of conclusive proof, hardwood floors appear to increase the value of a property. In addition to their aesthetic appeal, hardwood floors have a long lifespan and are quite simple to clean and maintain.

    When it comes to the flooring market, vinyl plank and tile are known for their durability. That it is more resistant to dampness and easier to maintain will be undeniable.

    But still, luxury vinyl plank vs engineered hardwood resale value, Vinyl plank resale value is less than Hardwood floors because they last longer and also give aesthetic appeal.

    Similarities between Engineered hardwood & Vinyl Plank:

    Both these options have some similarities too, which are:

    • There is a wide range of grains, colors, finishes, and plank widths in both Vinyl and engineered wood.
    • Vinyl and engineered wood are both durable and pet-friendly in different ways.
    • In each category, there are water-resistant versions.
    • Simple damp mopping is all that’s required to keep them sparkling.
    • With the correct equipment and a little DIY know-how, installation of both can be done in a matter of minutes.

    What is better Engineered Hardwood or Vinyl?

    Both these flooring options provide different features & can be great options according to different requirements. So it is important to know your requirements first. 

    Choosing engineered hardwood instead of Vinyl is a good option if you want to have a look and feel of real hardwood at a fraction of the cost. The fact that this flooring option is also environmentally friendly and will raise the value of your property are additional advantages.

    On the other hand, Vinyl plank flooring may be a better option for families with children since it requires less care, is more resistant to moisture and scratching, and is also less expensive.

    So both of these options are best in their own features & places. 

    Is luxury vinyl plank better than engineered hardwood?

    Yes, it is better than engineered hardwood in some terms. Like, the water resistance, ease of maintaining and cleaning, cost, and variety it offers is better than engineered hardwood. However, if you are looking for a premium look flooring option, which is durable and long-lasting, then engineered hardwood flooring is totally the better option.

    So simply saying, both these options are good in their own features. 

    Bottom Line

    So this was all about Engineered Hardwood vs vinyl plank. When deciding on flooring for your place, check your requirements & then look for these features in the two options. The one fulfilling all of them should be ideal for your place. 

    If you’re looking for a low-maintenance, budget-friendly flooring option that’s also highly durable and simple to install, look no further. You’re going to love all that vinyl plank has to offer.

    If you’re looking for a durable flooring option that requires less care than conventional hardwoods and is available in a range of colors and wood species, you can’t go wrong with engineered hardwoods.

    We hope this article was helpful & informative. Leave your valuable thoughts & suggestions in the comments. 

    Thank you for reading!